Four Suspects Arrested in Fatal Shooting of 17-Year-Old KayLee Dutton

The Cedar City community is in mourning following the tragic death of 17-year-old KayLee Dutton in a fatal shooting on January 17, 2025. Four suspects have been arrested in connection with the crime, marking a crucial step toward justice for KayLee and her family.

The Incident: A Deadly Pursuit

The events leading to KayLee’s untimely death began on January 17 at approximately 10:42 p.m. KayLee was driving a red pickup truck with a passenger when they were pursued by another vehicle flashing its high beams. The pursuit started on Lund Highway, continued along Midvalley Road, and ended near the Three Peaks Recreation Area.

Ka’Niyah Baker Death & Obituary: Arrests Made in Shocking Murder Case

According to Iron County Sheriff Ken Carpenter, the suspect vehicle pulled alongside KayLee’s truck and opened fire, striking the driver’s side multiple times. KayLee was critically injured and later died at Cedar City Hospital. Her passenger sustained a leg injury and remains hospitalized.

Arrests: Four Suspects Taken Into Custody

Less than 24 hours after the shooting, Iron County Metro SWAT officers executed a search warrant at a townhome complex west of Lund Highway. Three suspects were arrested at the location, and a fourth was apprehended at his workplace later that day.

The suspects and their charges include:

  • Ethan Galloway and Michael Hess-Witucki: Charged with second-degree felony murder, 12 counts of felony discharge of a firearm, marijuana possession, and possession of a dangerous weapon by a restricted person.
  • Matthew Sorber-Petrie and Aldric Felipe: Charged with obstructing justice, marijuana possession, and weapon possession.

Sheriff Carpenter expressed confidence in the arrests, stating, “We feel pretty good we have our suspects.”

Investigation: Evidence and Community Support

Law enforcement continues to investigate the crime, with search teams recovering evidence, including .223 caliber shell casings, near the crime scene. Forensic experts are processing the suspects’ apartment and vehicle while detectives conduct interviews and follow leads.

“This is a complex investigation requiring thorough work,” Carpenter explained. “We are committed to connecting all the pieces.”

A Community in Mourning

Although authorities have not formally identified the victim, family and friends have confirmed her as KayLee Dutton through social media posts and crowdfunding campaigns. KayLee was remembered as a bright and kind-hearted young woman whose life was tragically cut short.

Vigils and memorials have been held in her honor, with heartfelt tributes pouring in from across the Cedar City community. A crowdfunding campaign has been launched to support KayLee’s family during this difficult time.

Calls for Change

The tragic death of KayLee has reignited concerns about gun violence and public safety in Iron County. Community leaders and residents are urging action to address the root causes of violent crime and implement stronger preventative measures.

“This senseless act of violence is a wake-up call for our community,” said a local advocate. “We must come together to ensure the safety of our children and prevent future tragedies.”

The Legal Process Ahead

As of Sunday morning, formal charges against the suspects had not yet been filed in the 5th District Court. Sheriff Carpenter emphasized the importance of justice, stating, “We are committed to holding those responsible accountable for their actions.”

The passenger in KayLee’s truck is recovering from her injuries and will provide a formal statement once she is ready, ensuring an accurate account of the events.

Conclusion

The fatal shooting of KayLee Dutton has left an indelible mark on Cedar City, uniting the community in grief and a shared determination to seek justice. The arrests of four suspects represent a significant step in the legal process, but the road to healing and accountability continues.

KayLee’s memory serves as a powerful reminder of the devastating impact of violence. As the investigation proceeds, her story underscores the need for community-driven solutions to prevent such tragedies and ensure a safer future for all.

Leave a Comment